基于蒙卡-点核积分耦合的核电厂退役辐射场计算

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 针对核电厂退役现场中复杂和简单几何区域并存的问题,以及退役过程对辐射场计算提出的快速、准确的要求,提出了蒙卡和点核积分耦合计算方法,并开发了耦合计算程序。对于单体源模型,由于模型简单,耦合方法、点核方法与蒙卡方法的计算结果均较接近,相对偏差小于10%,但耦合方法的计算速度比蒙卡方法提高了3.5倍;采用耦合方法和蒙卡方法分别计算了多体源模型的辐射场,结果表明耦合方法的计算准确度较高,相对蒙卡方法偏差小于40%,计算时间约为蒙卡方法的1/5。以秦山一期退役辐射场为例开展了计算分析,结果显示,耦合方法与蒙卡方法的计算结果相差不超过1个数量级,但前者计算速度比后者提高了约3倍,说明耦合方法可以满足核电厂退役辐射场计算需要。

关键词: 蒙卡, 点核积分, 耦合, 退役, 辐射场

Abstract: In view of the coexistence of complex and simple geometrical areas in the decommissioning site of nuclear power plants, and the requirements of speediness and accuracy for the radiation field calculation during decommissioning process, a coupling calculation method of Monte Carlo and point kernel integration is proposed. Besides, a coupling calculation program is developed. For the single source model, due to the simpleness of this model, the results of the coupling method, the point kernel integration method and the Monte Carlo method are all close, and the relative deviations are less than 10%; but the calculation speed of the coupling method is 3.5 times as fast as that of the Monte Carlo method. Then the radiation field of the multi-body source model is calculated by the coupling method and the Monte Carlo method. The results show that the calculation accuracy of the coupling method is relatively high, the deviations are less than 40%, and the calculation time is shortened to 1/5 compared with the Monte Carlo method. The decommissioning radiation field of Qinshan phase I is calculated. The results demonstrate that the calculation results of the coupling method and the Monte Carlo method differ by no more than one order of magnitude, and the calculation speed of the former increases by 3 times than the latter, indicating that the coupling method can meet the needs of decommissioning radiation field calculation of nuclear power plants.

Key words: Monte Carlo, point kernel integration, coupling, decommissioning, radiation field

中图分类号:

TL943

郭雨非, 章航洲, 刘水清, 刘艳芳, 吴耀, 王力, 肖峰. 基于蒙卡-点核积分耦合的核电厂退役辐射场计算[J]. 辐射防护, 2021, 41(5): 459-466.

GUO Yufei, ZHANG Hangzhou, LIU Shuiqing, LIU Yanfang, WU Yao, WANG Li, XIAO Feng. Calculation of radiation field during nuclear power plant decommissioning based on the coupling of MC and point kernel integration[J]. RADIATION PROTECTION, 2021, 41(5): 459-466.

参考文献

[1] 罗上庚,张振涛,张华. 核设施与辐射设施的退役[M]. 北京:中国环境科学出版社, 2010:35-36.
LUO Shanggeng, ZHANG Zhentao, ZHANG Hua. Decommissioning of nuclear facilities and radiation facilities[M]. Beijing: China Environmental Science Press, 2010:35-36.
[2] IAEA. Decommissioning strategies for facilities using radioactive material[R]. Safety Reports Series, 2007(50):12-15.
[3] 肖雪夫. 贯穿核设施退役始终的重要工作之一——特性调查[C]//中国环境科学学会核安全与辐射环境安全专业委员会、中国核学会辐射防护分会、中华医学会放射医学与防护学分会、中华预防医学会放射卫生委员会. 21世纪初辐射防护论坛第三次会议暨21世纪初核安全论坛第一次会议论文集. 2004:65-68.
XIAO Xuefu. One of the important tasks throughout the decommissioning of nuclear facilities-the characteristics survey[C]// The Professional Committee of Nuclear Safety and Radiation Environment Safety of Chinese Environmental Sciences Society, the Radiation Protection Branch of Chinese Nuclear Society, the Branch of Radiological Medicine and Protection of Chinese Medical Society, and the radiological Health Committee of Chinese Preventive Medical Society. The proceedings of the 3^rd Meeting of the Forum on Radiation Protection in the Early 21^st Century and the 1^st Meeting of the Forum on Nuclear Safety in the Early 21^st Century. 2004:65-68.
[4] 黄治俭. 核设施退役工程中的辐射监测和质量保证[J]. 辐射防护通讯, 1992,12(3):14-19.
HUANG Zhijian. Radiation monitoring and quality assurance in the decommissioning project of nuclear facilities [J]. Radiation Protection Communications,1992,12(3):14-19.
[5] 张永领,胡一非,刘猛,等. 反应堆退役三维仿真关键技术研究[C]//中国核学会. 中国核学会2015年学术年会论文集. 北京:中囯原子能出版社, 2015:64-70.
ZHANG Yongling, HU Yifei, LIU Meng, et al. Study of the key technologies in the decommissioning simulation of nuclear reactors[C]// The proceedings of the Annual Conference in 2015 of Chinese Nuclear Society. Beijing: Atomic Energy Press, 2015:64-70.
[6] 张永领,胡一非,刘猛,等. 反应堆退役三维辐射场实时计算及可视化[J]. 辐射防护, 2018,38(1):19-25.
ZHANG Yongling, HU Yifei, LIU Meng, et al. Real-time calculation and visualization of 3D radiation field in the decommissioning of nuclear reactors[J]. Radiation Protection, 2018,38(1):19-25.
[7] 毕远杰,杨宏伟,郭金森,等. 研究堆退役中的快速辐射传输计算方法研究[J]. 原子能科学技术, 2015,49(S1):470-474.
BI Yuanjie, YANG Hongwei, GUO Jinsen, et al. Study on the fast calculation method for radiation transport in the decommissioning of research reactors[J]. Science and Technology of Atomic Energy, 2015,49(S1):470-474.
[8] 席福坤,方邦城. 计算γ射线点核积分的蒙特卡罗方法[J]. 核动力工程, 1987,8(2):66-74.
XI Fukun, FANG Bangcheng. Monte Carlo method for the point kernel integration calculation of gamma rays[J]. Nuclear Power Engineering, 1987,8(2):66-74.
[9] 伍盛煜. 三维γ辐射场的点核积分计算方法研究与程序设计[D]. 绵阳:中国工程物理研究院, 2018.
WU Shengyu. Research and program design of point kernel integration calculation method for 3D gamma radiation field[D]. Mianyang: Engineering Physics Institute of China, 2018.
[10] 赵杨. Bi₂Wo₆纳米结构的合成及其γ射线屏蔽性能研究[D]. 绵阳:西南科技大学, 2017.
ZHAO Yang. Study on the synthesis of Bi₂Wo₆ nanostructures and its shielding properties on gamma rays[D]. Mianyang: Southwestern University of Science and Technology, 2017.
[11] 祝美英,徐涛忠. 放射性存留量建模分析估算报告[R]. 成都:中国核动力研究设计院, 2018.
ZHU Meiying, XU Taozhong. Report of the modeling analysis and estimation on the radioactive retention[R]. Chengdu: Nuclear Power Institute of China, 2018.
[12] 郭亚平,付孟婷,张泽寰,等. 辐射场蒙卡-点核耦合计算方法研究[C]//中国核能行业协会第二届核电厂放射性废物管理研讨会论文集.2018:69-75.
GUO Yaping, FU Mengting, ZHANG Zehuan, et al. Study on the radiation field calculation method on the coupling of Monte Carlo and point kernel integration[C]//The proceeding of the 2^nd Symposium on the Radioactive Waste Management of Nuclear Power Plants of the Nuclear Energy Industry Association of China.2018:69-75.
[13] 毕远杰,郭金森,李传龙,等. 三维辐射场快速计算软件系统开发[J]. 中国原子能科学研究院年报,2017:190.
BI Yuanjie, GUO Jinsen, LI Chuanlong, et al. Development of rapid calculation software system for 3D radiation field[J]. Annual Report of Atomic Energy Institute of China, 2017:190.
[14] 毕远杰,杨宏伟,骆志平,等. 用于三维辐射场快速计算的耦合方法[J]. 中国原子能科学研究院年报,2013:246.
BI Yuanjie, YANG Hongwei, LUO Zhiping, et al. The coupling method for fast calculation of 3D radiation field[J]. Annual Report of Atomic Energy Institute of China, 2013:246.
[15] 韩静茹,陈义学,石生春,等. 基于离散纵标法与蒙特卡罗方法的三维耦合程序开发[J]. 核科学与工程, 2012,32(2):160-164.
HAN Jingru, CHEN Yixue, SHI Shengchun, et al. Development of 3D coupled code based on discrete ordinate method and Monte Carlo method[J]. Nuclear Science and Engineering, 2012,32(2):160-164.
[16] 杨德锋,薛娜,程和平,等. MCNP与DORT耦合计算方法研究[J]. 科技导报, 2013,31(18):53-56.
YANG Defeng, XUE Na, CHENG Heping, et al. Study on the coupling calculation method of MCNP and DORT[J]. Science and Technology Review, 2013,31(18):53-56.
[17] 欧阳予. 秦山核电厂的设计和建造[J]. 核动力工程, 1985,6(6):481-489.
OUYANG Yu. Design and construction of Qinshan nuclear power plant[J]. Nuclear Power Engineering, 1985,6(6):481-489.