美国核管会关于小型模块堆厂址人口要求的考虑及启示

辐射防护 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (1): 81-87.

美国核管会关于小型模块堆厂址人口要求的考虑及启示

熊小伟^1,2, 王一川¹, 李洋^1,2, 方圆^1,2, 陈晓秋¹, 杨端节¹, 毛玉仙¹, 商照荣¹

1.生态环境部核与辐射安全中心,北京 102445;
2.北京市辐射安全研究会,北京 100082

收稿日期:2020-05-12 出版日期:2021-01-20 发布日期:2021-03-15
通讯作者: 方圆。E-mail:fangyuan1014@126.com
作者简介:熊小伟(1981—),男,2005年本科毕业于大连理工大学环境工程专业,2008年硕士毕业于中国辐射防护研究院环境科学专业,高级工程师。E-mail:xiongxiaowei@chinansc.cn

Consideration and enlightenment from the population-related sitingreqirements of NRC for small modular reactors

XIONG Xiaowei^1,2, WANG Yichuan¹, YANG Li^1,2, FAN Yuan^1,2, CHEN Xiaoqiu¹, YANG Duanjie¹, MAO Yuxian¹, SHANG Zhaorong¹

1. Nuclear and Radiation Safety Center, Beijing 102445;
2. Beijing Society of Radiation Safety, Beijing 100082

Received:2020-05-12 Online:2021-01-20 Published:2021-03-15

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 本文介绍了美国核管理委员会(NRC)关于反应堆选址过程中与人口因素相关的审管要求和评估准则,详细分析了NRC针对小型模块堆对涉及厂址人口要求法规的4种修订方案,提出我国在制定小型堆厂址人口要求过程中需要关注的问题:(1)考虑到总体社会风险并从厂址比选的角度出发,建立一个恰当的反应堆距人口集中居住区(或人口中心)边界的距离是必要的。此外,从纵深防御考虑,小型堆厂址仍然需要与人口集中居住区保持一个适当的距离;(2)基于小型堆选址事故后果及影响范围,建立与大型商用核动力厂相同社会风险水平的评价指标(如事故工况下厂址周围的集体有效剂量)是有益的;(3)公众可接受性和选址政策也是小型堆能否靠近人口集中居住区的重要因素。

关键词: 小型模块堆, 人口中心, 人口集中居住区, 社会风险

Abstract: This paper introduced the U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) revision plans for the population-related siting considerations for advanced small modular reactors. Four options including their pros and cons which were developed by NRC for consideration to address siting questions for small advanced reactors had been analyzed in detail. The problems that should be paid attention to during site evaluation process for small modular reactors in China are put forward: (1) Considering the overall social risks and from the perspective of plant site comparison, it is necessary to establish an appropriate distance between the reactor and the boundary of the densely populated center (population center). In addition, taking the defense-in-depth concept into account, the small modular reactor site still needs to keep a proper distance from the densely populated center; (2) based on the radiological consequences and influence scope of the accident of small reactors, it is beneficial to develop an evaluation index with the equivalent social risk between small modular reactors and typical large LWR can be developed such as the collective effective dose around the plant site under accident conditions; (3) the public acceptance and siting policy are the important factors for whether the small modular reactors can be located near the densely populated center.

Key words: small modular reactor, population center, densely populated center, societal risk

中图分类号:

TL75+2.1

熊小伟, 王一川, 李洋, 方圆, 陈晓秋, 杨端节, 毛玉仙, 商照荣. 美国核管会关于小型模块堆厂址人口要求的考虑及启示[J]. 辐射防护, 2021, 41(1): 81-87.

XIONG Xiaowei, WANG Yichuan, YANG Li, FAN Yuan, CHEN Xiaoqiu, YANG Duanjie, MAO Yuxian, SHANG Zhaorong. Consideration and enlightenment from the population-related sitingreqirements of NRC for small modular reactors[J]. RADIATION PROTECTION, 2021, 41(1): 81-87.

参考文献

[1] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Metropolitan siting—A historic perspective[R].NRC,1978.
[2] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Report of the siting policy task force[R].NRC,1979.
[3] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Potential policy,licensing,and key technical issues for small modular nuclear reactor designs[R].NRC,2010.
[4] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Accident source terms and siting for small modular reactors and non-light water reactors[R].NRC,2016.
[5] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.NRC vision and strategy:safely achieving effective and efficient non-light water reactor mission readiness[R].NRC,2016.
[6] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Siting considerations related to population for small modular and non-light water reactors[R].NRC,2017.
[7] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Population-related siting considerations for advanced reactors[R].NRC,2020.
[8] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.General site suitability criteria for nuclear power stations[S].RG 4.7.NRC,2014
[9] Belles R J,Flanagan G F,Hale R E,et al.Advanced reactor siting policy considerations[R].Oak Ridge National Laboratory,2019.
[10] Llc Nuscale Power.Nuscale final safety analysis report (revision 4)[R].NuScale Power,LLC,2020.
[11] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Final safety evaluation report for the early site permit application for the clinch river nuclear site[R].NRC,2019.
[12] 核工业标准化研究所.模块式小型压水堆厂址适应性研究——小型压水堆非居住区、规划限制区和应急计划区相关法规标准[R]. 2013.
[13] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Approaches for expediting and establishing stages in the licensing process for commercial advanced reactors[R].NRC,2019.
[14] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Increasing the use of risk-informed and performance-based evaluation techniques and regulatory guidance[R].NRC,2019.
[15] Belles R J,Mays G T,Omitaomu O A,et al.Identification of selected areas to support federal clean energy goals using small modular reactors[R].Oak Ridge:Oak Ridge National Laboratory,2013.
[16] Belles R J,Omitaomu O A.Population sensitivity evaluation of two candidate locations for possible small modular reactor siting[R].Oak Ridge:Oak Ridge National Laboratory,2014.
[17] Belles R J,Harrison T J,Omitaomu O A.Evaluation of proposed Hampton roads area sites for using small modular reactors to support federal clean energy goals[R].Oak Ridge:Oak Ridge National Laboratory,2014.
[18] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Guidance for a technology-inclusive,risk-informed,and performance-based methodology to inform the licensing basis and content of applications for licenses,certifications,and approvals for non-light-water reactors:Regulatory Guide DG-1353[S].NRC,2019.
[19] U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission.Proposed rule:emergency preparedness for small modular reactors and other new technologies (RIN 3150-aj68;NRC-2015-0225)[R].NRC,2018.
[20] 苏州热工研究院有限公司,环境保护部核与辐射安全中心.核动力厂环境辐射防护规定:GB 6249—2011[S].北京:中国环境科学出版社,2011.
[21] 杨端节,李冰,陈晓秋,等.浅析核电厂周围人口分布的现状[J].中国人口资源与环境,2013,23(11):230-233.