星敏感器误差分析与补偿方法

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1674-1579.2017.01.003

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 星敏感器是目前航天器精度最高的姿态测量部件，其误差是影响姿态确定系统精度的关键要素.依据误差频率特性，系统地对星敏感器误差进行分析，主要阐述星敏感器低频误差和高频误差产生的原因以及当前的抑制与补偿方法.在此基础上，根据星敏感器误差的特点，展望星敏感器低频误差以及高频误差抑制与补偿方法的发展趋势.

关键词: 星敏感器, 低频误差, 高频误差, 抑制与补偿

Abstract: Star sensors are the most accurate attitude determination instruments in a satellite. The error of star sensor is the key point of the precision of attitude determination system. In this paper, the error sources of star sensor are summarized systematically according to the frequency characteristics. The error analysis, suppression and compensation methods are reviewed so as to provide references for further study. Based on these introductions, the development trend of error suppression and compensation for star sensor’s low frequency error and high frequency error is investigated.

Key words: star sensor, low frequency error, high frequency error, suppression and compensation

中图分类号:

庞博, 黎康, 汤亮, 李果. 星敏感器误差分析与补偿方法[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(1): 17-24.

PANG Bo, LI Kang, TANG Liang, LI Guo. Error Analysis and Compensation for Star Sensor[J]. , 2017, 43(1): 17-24.

参考文献

［1］LIEBE C C. Accuracy performance of star trackersA tutorial［J］.IE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems,2002,38(2):587599. ［2］李果,孔祥皓,刘凤晶,等.“高分四号”卫星遥感技术创新［J］.航天返回与遥感,2016,37(4):715. LI G, KONG X H, LIU F J, et al. GF4 satellite remote sensing technology innovation ［J］. Spacecraft Recovery＆Remote Sensing,2016,37(4):715. ［3］STANDARDIZATION E C F S. ECSSEST6020C, star sensors terminology and performance specification［S］.ESAESTEC, Noordwijk, the Netherlands， European Space Agency.2008. ［4］卢欣,武延鹏,钟红军,等.星敏感器低频误差分析［J］.空间控制技术与应用,2014,40(2):17. LU X, WU Y P, ZHONG H J, et al. low frequency error analysis of star sensor［J］.Aerospace Control and Application,2014,40(2):17. ［5］JORGENSEN P S, JORGENSEN J L, DENVER T, et al. Inflight quality and accuracy of attitude measurements from the CHAMP advanced stellar compass［J］.Acta Astronautica,2005,56(1):181186. ［6］JORGENSENA J L, DENVERA T, BETTOA M, et al. The PROBA satellite star tracker performance［J］.Acta Astronautica, 2005,56(1):153159. ［7］IWATA T. Precision geolocation determination and pointing managemen for the advanced land observing satellite (ALOS)［C］//International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium. New York:IEEE,2003. ［8］YUWANG L, JUNHONG L, YONGHE D, et al. Inflight quality evaluation of attitude measurements from STECE APS01 star tracker［J］.Acta Astronautica,2014,102:207216. ［9］王任享,王建荣.无地面控制点卫星摄影测量探讨［J］.测绘科学,2016,40(2):312. WANG R X, WANG J R, HU X Q. Discussion on satellite photogrammetry without ground control point［J］.Science of Surveying and Mapping,2016,40(2):312. ［10］QUANG L, WOODRUFF C, ASHTON S, et al. Noise estimation for star tracker calibration and enhanced precision attitude determination［C］//Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Information Fusion. Beltsville MD,2002:235242. ［11］WINKLER S, WIEDERMANN G, GOCKEL W. Highaccuracy onboard attitude estimation for the GMES Sentinel2 satellite: concept, design, and first results［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation and Control Conference and Exhibit. Washington D.C.:AIAA,2008. ［12］霍德聪,黄琳,李岩,等.星敏感器在轨测量误差分析［J］.遥感学报,2012,16(增刊):5760. Huo D C, Huang L, Li Y, et al. 2012. An analytical method of star tracker measurement errors ［J］.Journal of Remote Sensing,2012,16(Suppl):5760. ［13］WANG J, XIONG K, ZHOU H. Lowfrequency periodic error identification and compensation for star tracker attitude measurement［J］.Chinese Journal of Aeronautics,2012,25(4):615621. ［14］吕振铎,雷拥军.卫星姿态测量与确定［M］.北京:国防工业出版社,2013. ［15］王任享,王建荣,胡莘.卫星摄影姿态测定系统低频误差补偿［J］.测绘学报,2016,45(2):12730. WANG R X, WANG J R, HU Z. Lowfrequency errors compensation of attitude determination system in satellite photogrammetry［J］.Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica,2016,45(2):127130. ［16］何世民,汤亮.基于宽带宽测量的姿态确定方法［J］.空间控制技术与应用,2011,37(5):2025. HE S M, TANG L. Highbandwidth measurement based attitude determination［J］.Aerospace Control and Application,2011,37(5):2025. ［17］刘志全,杨淑利,濮海玲.空间太阳电池阵的发展现状及趋势［J］.航天器工程,2012,21(6):112118. LIU Z Q, YANG S L, PU H L. Developmentand trend of space solar array technology［J］.Aerospace Control and Application,2012,21(6):112118. ［18］谈树萍,黎康.压电材料异位配置的高频抖动自适应控制方法研究［C］//中国宇航学会深空探测技术专业委员会学术年会暨863计划“深空探测与空间实验技术”重大项目学术研讨会.北京：中国宇航学会，2009. ［19］霍红庆,马勉军,李云鹏,等.卫星微角颤振高精度测量技术［J］.传感器与微系统,2011,30(3):46. HUO H Q, MA M J, LI Y P, et al. High precision measurement technology of satellite’s anglemicrovibration［J］.Transducer and microsystem technologies,2011,30(3):46. ［20］胡海霞,汤亮,石恒,等.航天器GNC系统数学仿真技术研究现状及展望［J］.空间控制技术与应用,2016,42(3):18. HU H X, TANG L, SHI H, et al. Research anddevelopment of numerical simulation techniques for spacecraft GNC system［J］.Aerospace Control and Application,2016,42(3):18. ［21］金涛,李贞,李婷,等.提高光学遥感卫星图像几何精度总体设计分析［J］.宇航学报,2013,34(8):115965. JIN T, LI Z, LI T, et al.system design and analysis for improving geometric accuracy of highresolution optical remote sensing satellite image［J］.Journal of Astronautics,2013,34(8):11591165. ［22］BLARRE L, QUAKNINE J, ODDOSMARCEL L, et al. High accuracy sodern star trackers: recent improvements proposed on SED36 and HYDRA star trackers［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation, and Control Conference Proceedings. Washington D.C.:AIAA,2006. ［23］CALHOUN P, SEDLAK J, SUPERFIN E. Filtering Methods for Error Reduction in Spacecraft Attitude Estimation Using Quaternion Star Trackers［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation, and Control Conference. Washing ton D.C.:AIAA,2011. ［24］XIONG K, ZHANG C Q, LIU L D. Identification of star sensor lowfrequency error parameters［J］.IET Control Theory and Applications,2012,6(3):384393. ［25］KAI X, LIANGDONG L. Compensation for periodic star sensor measurement error on satellite［J］.Asian Journal of Control,2013,15(5):13041312. ［26］XIONG K, LIANG T, YONGJUN L. Multiple model Kalman filter for attitude determination of precision pointing spacecraft［J］.Acta Astronautica,2011,68(78):843852. ［27］熊凯,宗红,汤亮.星敏感器低频误差在轨校准方法研究［J］.空间控制技术与应用,2014,38(3):813. XIONG K, ZONG H, TANG L.On star sensor low frequency error inorbit calibration method ［J］.Aerospace Control and Application,2014,38(3):813. ［28］熊凯,汤亮,刘一武.基于地标信息的星敏感器低频误差标定方法［J］.空间控制技术与应用,2012,38(3):1115. XIONG K, TANG L, LIU Y W. Calibrationof star sensor’s low frequency error based on landmark information［J］.Aerospace Control and Application,2012,38(3):1115. ［29］XIONG K, ZONG H. Performance evaluation of star sensor low frequency error calibration［J］.Acta Astronautica,2014,98:2436. ［30］YUWANG L, JUNHONG L, YONGHE D, et al. Precessionnutation correction for star tracker attitude measurement of STECE satellite［J］.Chinese Journal of Aeronautics,2014,27(1):117123. ［31］IWATA T, UO M, KAWAHARA T. groundbased precision attitude determination using repeated smoothing with sequential rate bias and attitude estimation［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation, and Control Conference. Washington D.C.:AIAA,2010. ［32］SCHMIDT U, ELSTNER C, MICHEL K. ASTRO 15 star tracker flight experience and further improvements towards the ASTRO APS star tracker［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation and Control Conference and Exhibit.Washington D.C.:AIAA,2008. ［33］JIANRONG W, RENXIANG W, XIN H. Compensation lowfrequency errors in TH1 satellite［J］.Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences,2016,XLIB1:383387. ［34］王炯琦,矫媛媛,周海银,等.复杂卫星抖动下的星敏感器姿态测量数据处理技术［J］.电子与信息学报,2010,32(8):18851891. WNAG J Q, JIAO YY, ZHOU H Y, et al. Star sensor attitude measuring data processing technique in condition of complex satellite dithering［J］.Journal of Electronics & Information Technology,2010,32(8):18851891. ［35］马超,邓新蒲,杨俊刚,等.压缩感知与最小二乘联合的卫星姿态抖动估计［J］.航天电子对抗,2014,30(4):1821. MA C, DENG X P, YANG J G, et al.An estimation method of satellite attitude jitter based on CS and leastsquare［J］.Aerospace Electronic Warfare,2014,30(4):1821. ［36］MILLER S E, KIRCHMAN P, SUDEY J. Reaction wheel operational impacts on the GEOSN jitter environment［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation and Control Conference and Exhibit. Washington D.C.: AIAA,2007. ［37］IWATA T, KAWAHARA T, MURANAKA N, et al. Highbandwidth attitude determination using jitter measurements and optimal filtering［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation, and Control Conference. Washington D.C.:AIAA,2009. ［38］ALGRAIN M C, POWERS R M. Highbandwidth measurements of attitude jitter in small spacecraft［C］//AIAA Guidance, Navigation, and Control Conference. Washington D.C.:AIAA,1996. ［39］ALGRAIN M C, WOEHRER M K. Determination of attitude jitter in small satellites［J］.Proceedings of SPIE,Acquisition, Tracking, and Pointing, 1996,2739:215228. ［40］ALGRAIN M C. Highbandwidth attitude jitter determination for pointing and tracking systems［J］.Optical Engineering, 1997,36(7):20912100. ［41］ALGRAIN M C, POWERS R M, WOEHRER M K. Extended bandwidth spacecraft attitude determination using gyros and linear accelerometers［J］.Optical Spectroscopic Techniques and Instrumentation for Atmospheric and Space Research Ii,1996,2830:306318. ［42］臧强,高晶敏,杨鸿波,等.基于四频差动激光陀螺/星敏感器的卫星定姿算法［J］.电光与控制,2016,23(3):8791. ZANG Q, GAO J M, YANG H B, et al. Asatellite attitude determination algorithm based on fourmode differential laser gyro and star sensor［J］.Electronics Optics & Control, 2016,23(3):8791. ［43］关新,陈守磊,崔颖慧,等.超静敏捷卫星隔振与控制的动力学耦合及协同设计方法［J］.空间控制技术与应用,2015,41(1):215. GUAN X, CHEN S L, CUI Y H, et al. Dynamicscoupling and integrated design in vibration isolation and attitude control design of ultraquiet agile satellites［J］.Aerospace Control and Application,2015,41(1):215. ［44］王有懿,汤亮,何英姿.超静平台动力学建模与解耦控制［J］.空间控制技术与应用,2016,42(4):611.

[1]	王子寒, 严微, 曹哲, 刘山山, 程会艳, 刘梦尧. 一种强散射杂光下的快速星点提取算法[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2020, 46(6): 63-68.
[2]	雷拥军. 星敏感器姿态测量相对基准偏差在轨标校方法研究[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(6): 1-7.
[3]	卢欣, 李春艳, 李晓, 孙大开, 夏梦绮. 星光导航技术现状与发展综述[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(4): 1-8.
[4]	王海涌, 王腾飞, 钟红军, 王可东. 弹载捷联星敏感器强光规避策略及算法[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(4): 19-24.
[5]	周建涛, 张春明. 星敏感器瞬态效应仿真及抗干扰算法[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(4): 25-30.
[6]	郑循江, 叶志龙, 杨勤利, 孙朔冬. 一种多帧相关滤波的星敏感器像素非均匀性误差校正方法[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(4): 31-36.
[7]	隋杰, 程会艳, 余成武, 武延鹏, 王晓燕, 郑然. 星敏感器光轴热稳定性仿真分析方法[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(4): 37-41.
[8]	陈建峰, 余成武, 程会艳, 隋杰, 武延鹏. 基于Bipod结构的星敏感器遮光罩安装结构优化设计[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(4): 68-72.
[9]	程会艳, 钟红军, 王龙, 杨君, 郑然. 一种快速全天星图识别算法[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2017, 43(4): 73-78.
[10]	鹿瑞, 武延鹏. 动态拖尾星图模拟算法研究[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2016, 42(4): 57-.
[11]	郝云彩, 余成武, 梁士通, 梅志武, 骞伟中 . 新一代星敏感器遮光罩——碳纳米管遮光罩技术研究[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2016, 42(2): 1-7.
[12]	梁士通, 钟红军, 刘婧. 一种高精度星敏感器用遮光罩[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2016, 42(2): 53-56.
[13]	鲍雨波, 宗红, 张春青. RTS平滑滤波在事后姿态确定中的应用[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2015, 41(3): 18-22.
[14]	刘达, 钟红军, 李春江, 卢欣. 星敏感器调焦方法研究[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2015, 41(1): 59-62.
[15]	熊凯, 宗红, 汤亮. 星敏感器低频误差在轨校准方法研究[J]. 空间控制技术与应用, 2014, 40(3): 9-.